Contrary to the conventional beliefs of many environmentalists, new research shows that hydraulic fracturing has at least one major environmental benefit: saving water.
Most Americans are generally unfamiliar with fracing, but it is arguably an issue of critical importance – not only with respect to the environment but also in foreign policy and the economy.
The debate is typically framed by priorities. Those who care more about the environment typically oppose fracing. Those who care more about U.S. energy independence and domestic economic opportunities are usually fracing proponents.
However, a new study – published Dec. 20 by the University of Texas at Austin (UT-Austin) – disrupts the usual dichotomy. At a time when climate change scientists are increasingly concerned about the effects of drought, the UT-Austin research shows that the water-intensive fracing method of extracting natural gas actually saves water in the aggregate.
Texas experienced the most extreme drought on record in 2011, with up to 100 days of triple-digit temperatures resulting in record electricity demand and historically low reservoir levels.
Electricity produced using natural gas combustion turbines and natural gas combined-cycle generators requires roughly 30% of the water needed for coal-power plants. The study estimates that the amount of water saved by shifting a power plant from coal to natural gas is up to 50 times the amount of water lost in fracing to extract the natural gas from underground shale formations.
UT-Austin researchers estimate that for every gallon of water used to frac for natural gas, Texas saved 33 gallons of water by using that gas for electricity generation rather than producing the same amount of power with coal.
“During the 2011 drought, if Texas’ natural gas-fired power plants had generated electricity with coal, the state would have consumed an additional 32 billion gallons of water, or enough to supply about 870,000 people with water, accounting for water used for fracing,” according to the study.
The analysis quantified water and electricity demand and supply for all 423 of the state’s power plants during the drought relative to 2010 (baseline). In 2011, researchers estimated that Texas would have consumed an extra 32 billion gallons of water if all its natural gas-fired power plants were instead burning coal.
“Drought raised electricity demands/generation by 6% – increasing water demands/consumption for electricity by 9%,” according to the study. “Reductions in monitored reservoir storage less than 50% of capacity in 2011 would suggest drought vulnerability, but data show that the power plants were flexible enough at the plant level to adapt by switching to less water-intensive technologies.
“Natural gas – now approximately 50% of power generation in Texas – enhances drought resilience by increasing the flexibility of power-plant generators, including gas-combustion turbines to complement increasing wind generation and combined-cycle generators with approximately 30% of cooling-water requirements of traditional steam-turbine plants,” researchers wrote. “These reductions in water use are projected to continue to 2030 with increased use of natural gas and renewables.”
Commenting on the new report, Bridget Scanlon, senior research scientist at UT’s Bureau of Economic Geology and lead author of the study, said, “The bottom line is that hydraulic fracturing, by boosting natural gas production and moving the state from water-intensive coal technologies, makes our electric-power system more drought-resilient.”
Contact the author, Kristie Sotolongo, at ksotolongo@hartenergy.com.
Recommended Reading
Eversource to Sell Sunrise Wind Stake to Ørsted
2024-04-19 - Eversource Energy said it will provide service to Ørsted and remain contracted to lead the onshore construction of Sunrise following the closing of the transaction.
Exclusive: Building Battery Value Chain is "Vital" to Energy Transition
2024-04-18 - Srini Godavarthy, the CEO of Li-Metal, breaks down the importance of scaling up battery production in North America and the traditional process of producing lithium anodes, in this Hart Energy Exclusive interview.
High Interest Rates a Headwind for the Energy Transition
2024-04-18 - Persistent high interest rates will make transitioning to a net zero global economy much harder and more costly, according to Wood Mackenzie Head of Economics Peter Martin.
Scotland Ditches 2030 Climate Target to Cut Emissions by 75%
2024-04-18 - Scotland was constrained by cuts to the capital funding it receives from the British government and an overall weakening of climate ambition by British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, said Mairi McAllan, the net zero secretary for Scotland's devolved government.
Exclusive: Mitsubishi Power Plans Hydrogen for the Long Haul
2024-04-17 - Mitsubishi Power is looking at a "realistic timeline" as the company scales projects centered around the "versatile molecule," Kai Guo, the vice president of hydrogen infrastructure development for Mitsubishi Power, told Hart Energy's Jordan Blum at CERAWeek by S&P Global.